Stop Criminalizing Poverty



On November 16, the San Leandro City Council is set to vote on changes to our municipal code “relating to standing or sitting on traffic medians or near curbs.” While the city has tried to present this as a change to increase traffic safety and relieve road congestin, the reality is that it is merely another attempt at anti-panhandling laws that criminalize poverty and infringe free speech.

In fact, some members of the City Council said exactly as much at their September 8 meeting, specifically the mayor and vice mayor! You can look up the relevant information on their website at https://sanleandro.legistar.com/MeetingDetail.aspx?ID=754137&GUID=35FDF636-2AE8-48FE-8AF2-E18471022DD3&Options=info|&Search=, beginning at Item 10.C. The older meeting records are available at https://sanleandro.legistar.com/MeetingDetail.aspx?ID=754132&GUID=7A8CE643-C818-4D9B-AECE-55D23C7C71CC&Options=info|&Search=, beginning at Item 8.M.

Notably, the Supreme Court ruled in Norton v. Springfield (2015) that nearly all anti-panhandling legislation was unconstitutional after legal challenges by organizations such as the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) and National Homeless Law Center (NHLC). Indeed, these organizations have repeatedly provided evidence showing that anti-panhandling laws are unfair as well as fail to address the underlying causes of homelessness and poverty in communities. In fact, they make it worse by putting arrest records, fines, and fees in the way of those trying to exit homelessness.

Meanwhile, studies show providing housing and services costs 2 to 3 times less than cycling homeless individuals through the criminal justice system. Indeed, panhandlers predominantly spend any money they receive on food and other necessities, make less than $300 per month on average, and that people panhandling will work if given the opportunity and means to do so.

However, repealing or reversing anti-panhandling ordinances does not mean promoting rampant or aggressive panhandling. What it means is freeing up those resources that can then be redirected to critical services that will actually end the need for people to require this kind of help in the first place.

More importantly, if churches can solicit donations at our doorsteps, if Westboro Baptists can picket hateful images at military funerals, and if the Girl Scouts can sell cookies right outside BART – then why can’t people who are at one of the lowest points in their life and desperate for a little help be allowed to ask for it?

Please contact our City Councilmembers and tell them to vote no on this item! We need to stop this blatant attempt to violate free speech and criminalize poverty immediately, particularly given the ongoing issues with violence and misconduct within the San Leandro Police Department. (As you’ve probably read in my other posts.)

If not, we could expect significant costs related to litigation, the expenditure of unnecessary law enforcement resources, as well as furthering dehumanizing oppression of our low-income and homeless populations. Just see what’s happening right now with Sacramento at https://www.aclunc.org/news/lawsuit-charges-sacramento-s-anti-panhandling-ordinance-unconstitutional.

You can contact our elected officials via the below emails and phone numbers, as well as our city manager and city attorney:

Mayor Pauline Cutter
Phone: (510) 577-3355
Email: pcutter@sanleandro.org

Vice Mayor Peter Ballew
Phone: (510) 577-3357
Email: pballew@sanleandro.org

Councilwoman Deborah Cox
Phone: (510) 577-3357
Email: dcox@sanleandro.org

Councilman Ed Hernandez
Phone: (510) 577-3357
Email: ehernandez@sanleandro.org

Councilman Victor Aguilar
Phone: (510) 577-3357
Email: vaguilar@sanleandro.org

Councilman Benny Lee
Phone: (510) 577-3357
Email: blee@sanleandro.org

Councilwoman Corina Lopez
Phone: (510) 577-3357
Email: clopez@sanleandro.org

City Manager Jeff Kay
Phone: (510) 577-3351
Email: JKay@sanleandro.org

City Attorney Richard Rio Poda
Phone: (510) 577-6098
Email: rpioroda@meyersnave.com

For more information about this topic and explanations dispelling myths about panhandling, I encourage people to visit the NHLC’s website at https://nlchp.org/panhandling/. There are also some great articles available at https://theconversation.com/most-panhandling-laws-are-unconstitutional-since-theres-no-freedom-from-speech-92498, https://law.yale.edu/sites/default/files/area/center/schell/criminalization_of_homelessness_report_for_web_full_report.pdf, and https://www.pewtrusts.org/en/research-and-analysis/blogs/stateline/2015/11/12/anti-panhandling-laws-spread-face-legal-challenges.

Take note and take care.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

San Leandro Crime Rates: What's Happening?

Image
(Photo credit: SF Chronicle ) If you live in the Bay Area, you've probably been inundated with hysteria about the local crime rate from catalytic converter thefts to store burglaries. So what's happening in San Leandro? Well, let's dig into the data.  https://www.sanleandro.org/449/Crime-Analysis . I looked at the December 2022 Uniform Crime Report (UCR) for the most recent data. Total YTD Crimes for 2022 are almost the same as they were in 2019, within 5% of each other. Thankfully, nearly all of that is property crime and not violent crime (property crime is, coincidentally, 95% of all crime in 2022 and 2019). Still, it's hard to call crime going back to pre-pandemic levels as we continue to transition out of the pandemic anything other than a return to normal. Albeit, a still unsatisfactory normal. I say unsatisfactory because total YTD arrests have continued to decrease significantly since 2017, when the high was 2,799 compared to 2022's 1,292. It's unclear
Read more

A Brief History of Zionism

Image
( From JTA ) I cannot help but notice a lot of disinformation, ignorance, and bigotry coming from people who call themselves pro-Palestinian and/or pro-Israel as this conflict continues to spiral into ever more suffering. Sometimes, I feel like the best thing I can do when struggling amidst human tragedy is to focus on education as a path for compassion, understanding, and solidarity. Since I am Jewish, I will tell a story of my people. So, I am here to share a little bit about the history of Zionism , which at its core is the belief in the Jewish people's right to self-determination in their ancestral homeland. While Zionism has this central core meaning, there are several expressions (or "flavors") of it in practice: political, revisionist, labor, cultural, religious, practical, reform, & radical. There's actually even green Zionism! But all forms tie back, in some form or another to Israel - actually Yisrael, whether Am (the people), Eretz (the land), Medina
Read more

HOPE for Housing in San Leandro

Image
Do you believe everyone deserves a safe place to call home? It's a simple question really, but for some people, the answer isn't. As far back as 1944 , we've known that housing is a human right. Even now, when we think of the "American Dream" we think of housing. We imagine a place to live and call our own. So much of our identity and community is intertwined with the place we think of as home. But for many people in San Leandro that's impossible. The minimum wage here is $15.50 per hour . Assuming you are getting shifts full-time, your annual earnings before taxes are $32,240. Meanwhile, the median rent for a studio apartment is $1,849 per month. That's $22,188 per year. You now have $10,052 left for everything else . Oh, but wait, taxes are actually $5,408! Now you only have $4,644 for groceries, utilities, internet, transportation, health insurance, and maybe some clothes to wear. For the entire year. After rent and taxes, you have to live on $387 pe
Read more